A majority of Japanese companies have no interest in being included in stock indexes guided by environmental, social and governance (ESG) principles, a Reuters poll found, even as pressure grows on firms to lift their management standards following a string of corporate scandals.
Investment in ESG indexes is expected to grow after Japan’s Government Pension Investment Fund, which manages $1.3 trillion, decided earlier this year to raise its ESG allocation to 10 percent of its stock holdings from 3 percent.
The pension fund’s shift follows problems that have put the focus on Japan Inc’s management. These include the accounting scandal at Toshiba Corp (>> Toshiba Corp), Kobe Steel Ltd’s (>> Kobe Steel, Ltd.) data fabrication and Nissan Motor Co’s (>> Nissan Motor Co Ltd) revelation that uncertified technicians had been carrying out vehicle inspections.
However, despite increased awareness around corporate responsibility issues, a Reuters Corporate survey showed 56 percent of 247 companies polled were not aware of ESG indexes, and only 6 percent said their companies were included in one. Some 72 percent of companies said they were not included and 22 percent said they didn’t know.
And of the 174 companies that said they aren’t included in such indexes, 144 said they had no interest in joining them, accounting for 58 percent of the entire survey sample.
“Companies that make ESG efforts do not necessarily report strong earnings,” wrote a manager at a wholesale company.
A manager at a food company was also dismissive: “Companies should contribute to society by paying more taxes and not bother with ESG criteria.”
Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has been pushing for greater corporate governance and transparency.
GPIF in July chose three indexes to guide its investments in the area: the FTSE Blossom Japan index, which includes 150 companies, the MSCI Japan ESG Select Leaders index (252 stocks) and the MSCI Japan Empowering Women index (211 stocks).
The companies in the indexes were selected based on criteria including labour practices, efforts to prevent global warming and the use of toxic substances and board of directors selection.
In a drive to improve corporate governance at Japanese companies and make them more attractive to foreign investors, GPIF signed the U.N.-supported Principles for Responsible Investment, or PRI, in 2015.
Both Kobe Steel and Nissan are included in the MSCI Japan ESG Select Leaders index.
The survey for Reuters by Nikkei Research, conducted Oct. 26-Nov. 7, polled 400 big and mid-sized businesses. A total of 247 firms, which reply on condition of anonymity, answered the questions on ESG.
Source: Reuters (Reporting by Ayai Tomisawa; Editing by Malcolm Foster and Sam Holmes)